British Pies vs American Pot Pies
What’s The Difference?
For many Americans discovering British food for the first time, there’s one question that comes up again and again:
“Aren’t British pies just pot pies?” Not quite.
While both are comforting, hearty dishes filled with meat and gravy, British pies and American pot pies are actually very different things, both in tradition and in how they’re made.
And if you ask most Brits, they’ll tell you there’s absolutely no comparison.
What Is A British Pie?
A proper British pie is one of the cornerstones of British comfort food.
Traditionally, British pies are made with slow-cooked meat and rich gravy, fully enclosed in pastry or topped with pastry depending on the style. The pastry itself matters just as much as the filling.
In Britain, pies are everywhere:
- Football grounds
- Pubs
- Bakeries
- Chip shops
- Family dinners
- Cold picnic spreads
They’re not seen as novelty comfort food. They’re everyday food.
Classic British pie fillings include:
- Steak & Ale
- Steak & Kidney
- Chicken & Mushroom
- Minced Beef & Onion
- Lamb & Mint
- Cottage Pie (no pastry here though just mashed potato topping!)
- Shepherd’s Pie (no pastry here either just mashed potato topping!)
At Parker’s Great British Institution, we make our pies using traditional British recipes, proper imported British seasoning, and old-school methods, right here in America.
What Is An American Pot Pie?
American pot pies are typically softer, creamier, and usually served as a full casserole-style meal.
They often feature:
- A creamy sauce
- Mixed vegetables throughout
- A pastry lid
- Softer pastry texture
- Chicken as the most common filling
They’re usually baked in a dish and eaten with a spoon, whereas many British pies are designed to hold their shape and can often be eaten by hand.
American pot pies also tend to focus less on the pastry itself. In Britain, the pastry is part of the experience.
A soggy pie in Britain is practically a national tragedy!
The Biggest Difference? The Pastry.
This is where Brits become particularly opinionated.
British pies use one of 3 different types, depending on the pie:
- Hot water crust pastry
- Puff pastry
- Shortcrust pastry
The pastry is expected to have structure, texture, and bite.
American pot pies usually prioritise the filling first, with the pastry acting more as a topping.
For Brits, a proper pie should feel substantial.
British Pie Culture Runs Deep
Britain’s love affair with pies goes back centuries.
Pies were originally practical, hearty meals designed to feed workers through cold weather and long days. Over time, regional pie traditions developed across the UK, from Melton Mowbray pork pies to steak pies in Scotland and Cornish pasties in the South West.
Today, pies remain one of Britain’s most nostalgic comfort foods.
For many British expats living in America, finding a proper pie is one of the things they miss most.
Where Can You Buy Authentic British Pies In America?
That’s exactly why Parker’s Great British Institution exists we started by bringing Pork Pies to America.
We make authentic British Pies in America using traditional recipes and proper British methods, then ship them nationwide across the United States.
From Steak & Ale Pie and Chicken & Mushroom Pie to pork pies, sausage rolls, and classic British comfort food favourites, we help Brits across America enjoy a real taste of home.
If you’re going to eat British food, do it properly.
Comments (0)
There are no comments for this article. Be the first one to leave a message!